Healthy, wealthy and wise

Notes on health, money and faith, by Koot Jordaan

Faith › The church

The church: measuring ourselves against Acts

In the series The churchPart 1 of 3

This morning, while I was talking to the Lord, a question came to me. I asked ChatGPT to compare the congregation in Acts with the church of today, using everything it has to draw on: the Bible, sermons, books and so on. I think it was fairly on the mark [1]. What I like best is the list at the end, which any congregation can use to measure itself against Jesus’ congregation in Acts. It forms part of how I am thinking about discipleship.

So let us measure ourselves and our churches against Acts. How do you and I, and our congregations, come out?

Where Acts begins

Acts does not begin with a building, an organisation, a denomination or a weekly programme. It begins with a command, a promise and a sending:

“But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes upon you, and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, in all Judea and Samaria, and to the farthest corner of the earth.” (Acts 1:8)

The question was not “How do we build a strong local organisation?” It was “How do we reach the world with the gospel of Jesus Christ?”

The core difference

In Acts, the congregation was mainly a movement of disciples who were sent out. Today it often works mainly as an institution where people gather [1]. That changes almost everything. Here is the comparison, with the “today” side as ChatGPT sees it [1]:

  • Identity. Acts: disciples of Jesus. Today: members and regular attenders. Membership can replace discipleship.
  • Power. Acts: the Holy Spirit. Today: often organisation, training, money and technology.
  • Mission. Acts: going to the people. Today: getting people to come. The unreached stay unreached.
  • Witness. Acts: ordinary believers testify. Today: often specialists and preachers, and much of the body goes passive.
  • Baptism. Acts: straight after believing. Today: sometimes weeks, months or years later [2].

The same pattern shows in fellowship, possessions, leaders, buildings, unity and how we measure success, which I take in turn below. ChatGPT was careful to add that this is a broad comparison. Many congregations today show strong Acts characteristics, and Acts itself describes sin, conflict, false teaching, division and weak people. We are not comparing a perfect first-century church with “bad modern Christians”. We are comparing patterns.

Participants, not spectators

Of the first believers, Acts 2:42 says: “They kept on in the teaching of the apostles, in fellowship, in the breaking of bread and in prayers.” Notice: they kept on. The apostles did not do everything while the rest watched.

When persecution broke out in Jerusalem, something remarkable happened: “Those who were scattered went through the land and spread the word of the gospel.” (Acts 8:4) Acts 8:1 tells us the apostles stayed in Jerusalem. Ordinary believers carried the gospel.

Go, not come

Jesus said: “Go into the whole world and proclaim the gospel to all people.” (Mark 16:15) And: “Go, then, and make disciples of all nations.” (Matthew 28:19) The movement in Acts is outward all the time.

The modern model can easily turn this around: build, organise, advertise, invite, come and listen. There is nothing wrong with believers meeting; it is essential. The trouble starts when the meeting replaces the mission. Then “go to them” quietly becomes “we hope they come to us”. The people who will never walk into a Christian meeting may never hear the gospel.

Power and a shared life

Jesus told the disciples to wait in Jerusalem until they were equipped with power from on high (Luke 24:49). The pattern in Acts is not only plan, budget, committee, carry out. It is pray, listen, the Spirit leads, obey, go. When that dependence disappears, an organisation can run very efficiently without being spiritually powerful.

Peter’s answer on the day of Pentecost was simple: “Repent, and let each one of you be baptised in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.” (Acts 2:38) The pattern is: believe, repent, obey, be baptised, receive, follow, learn, witness.

Their life was woven together: “Day by day they stayed together in the temple, and from house to house they broke bread.” (Acts 2:46) “I am going to church on Sunday” is actually foreign to Acts. The congregation was not mainly somewhere they went. They WERE the congregation. Where they went, the body of Christ went.

Money had a different centre too: “For there was nobody among them who was in need.” (Acts 4:34) Those with means gave freely to those without. Acts 6 shows there was administration too, but it existed to serve people, not to keep itself going. When a large part of our resources today goes to buildings, salaries, administration and programmes [3], Acts forces us to ask: how much of it reaches the harvest field?

Leaders, unity and what we count

Ephesians 4:11-12 says leaders are given “to equip the saints for their work of service”. So the pattern is: leader equips, believers serve. Not: leader serves, believers watch. In that second model perhaps 5% of the body becomes active while 95% stay receivers [4]. That is an enormous loss of potential sowers.

Unity was part of the mission. Jesus prays “that all may be one … so that the world may believe that you sent me.” (John 17:21) When one town has dozens of independent groups with little to do with each other, each may love Jesus sincerely, but the visible witness of “one body” is harder to see.

And what do we count? Today we ask how many attend and how big the budget is. Acts speaks differently: “The word of God increased” (Acts 6:7) and “the word of the Lord grew with power and prevailed” (Acts 19:20). So the question becomes: how many disciples are being formed and sent out? And sharper: how many of them make disciples in turn? That is multiplication.

A test for any congregation

I have drawn this sharply on purpose, and many congregations do much more than this. But it shows the structural danger: the first model multiplies workers, the second can produce consumers. If the Great Commission belongs to the whole body of Christ, a passive believer is not simply a slightly less committed disciple. He said: “I chose you and appointed you to go and bear fruit.” (John 15:16) Notice the verb: go.

So we can test almost any congregation with ten simple questions:

  1. Are people really becoming disciples of Jesus, or mainly regular attenders?
  2. Are they being equipped to share the gospel themselves?
  3. Are new believers taught to make other disciples in turn?
  4. Is the Holy Spirit in practice the source of power and guidance?
  5. Is prayer central?
  6. Is there real, daily fellowship and care for one another?
  7. Are the poor and needy looked after?
  8. Does a meaningful share of money and energy flow to the harvest?
  9. Does the body of Christ in a town visibly work together?
  10. Is the end result multiplication?

And then the uncomfortable question: if we took away all our buildings, denomination names, programmes, titles, liturgies and traditions for a moment, how much of what is left would still look like Acts?

I think that is the most important question. Acts shows what happens when ordinary people take Jesus seriously, are empowered by the Holy Spirit, obey the Word and start sowing. That is why, without modern transport, internet, radio, television or big institutional infrastructure, the gospel travelled from Jerusalem to Rome within a few decades [5]. It was not mainly an attendance model. It was a multiplication model.

The next part in this series looks at the seed and the sowers.

Sources

  1. SOURCE NEEDED: The comparison of the congregation in Acts with "the church today", and the whole "today" side of the list (members instead of disciples, a weekly meeting, buildings at the centre, specialists doing the witnessing, many denominations). It came from ChatGPT, which Koot asked to generalise from "the Bible, sermons, books etc". Koot named no book, preacher or study. Unverified. ↑
  2. SOURCE NEEDED: That baptism today often happens weeks, months or years after someone comes to faith (ChatGPT; unverified). ↑
  3. SOURCE NEEDED: That a large part of congregations' resources goes to buildings, salaries, administration and programmes (ChatGPT; unverified; no figures given). ↑
  4. SOURCE NEEDED: "Perhaps 5% of the body becomes active while 95% remain receivers." ChatGPT said "perhaps" and gave no source. Name a source or cut the figure. ↑
  5. SOURCE NEEDED: That the gospel spread from Jerusalem to Rome within a few decades, without modern transport or media (ChatGPT; a historical claim, unverified). ↑
All 3 parts in this series
  1. The church: measuring ourselves against Acts
  2. The church: the seed and the sowers
  3. The church: one body, many parts

More from Faith

All Faith articles →