It is now 13 years since I read the book Spark by John Ratey, about how good exercise is for keeping the brain in shape. The day I closed the book I started to exercise, and I started to read up on health: what can I do to stay as healthy as possible for as long as possible? That includes my brain.
Recently I read an article by Dr Mercola on krill oil [1]. As I understood it, he sees krill oil as the best source of omega-3 fatty acids, and he explains why those fats matter so much for brain cells [1]. I then had a long conversation with an AI chat tool about the article [2]. This post is my summary of what the article is said to argue, plus what the chat added. These are Dr Mercola’s views, not established fact. And everything from the chat is unchecked.
What the article is said to argue
The first idea is about the form the omega-3 comes in. In krill oil, the omega-3 fats EPA and DHA are said to be bound to phospholipids [3]. Phospholipids are the building blocks of every cell membrane, especially in the brain, the nerves, the eyes and the heart [4]. Because the omega-3 is already attached to them, Dr Mercola argues it is built into cell membranes more easily and is often better available to the body than ordinary fish oil [5]. Fish oil, in this picture, carries its DHA in triglycerides, and krill oil carries it in phospholipids [5].
He also stresses that these phospholipids help keep cell membranes supple and working, that they act as “gatekeepers” for what moves in and out of cells, and that they may help DHA reach the brain more easily [6].
Two more things are said to be in krill oil. One is choline, which the body uses to make acetylcholine, a messenger in the brain that matters for learning, memory, attention and concentration [7]. The other is astaxanthin, a natural antioxidant that gives krill oil its red colour and is said to protect the fragile omega-3 fats from oxidation [8].
DHA as building material
DHA is the part that fascinated me most. The chat said the brain is a physical structure of about 86 billion neurons, each with thousands of connections, and that their membranes are made largely of phospholipids and fatty acids [9]. DHA is not just a fuel. It is built into those membranes, especially in the brain, the retina and nerve cells, where it is found in high concentrations [10].
The chat compared it to steel in reinforced concrete. You don’t see it, but without it the building eventually collapses [10]. When DHA is plentiful, so the chat said, membranes stay supple, receptors work better, signals move more easily and new connections form more easily [11]. Research links DHA to normal brain development and function [11].
Where exercise comes in
According to the chat, John Ratey shows in Spark that exercise raises a substance called BDNF, stimulates new connections, promotes the brain’s ability to adapt (neuroplasticity) and helps new neurons survive [12]. The chat’s picture was this: if BDNF is the building foreman, DHA is one of the bricks [13]. One says “build new connections” and the other supplies the material. That is perhaps why exercise and enough omega-3 might complement each other for brain health [13]. Note the word “perhaps”.
The careful notes
The chat itself was careful on one point, and so should we be. Some studies do show higher availability of DHA that is bound to phospholipids. But it has not been definitively proven that this leads to better long-term results than high-quality fish oil [14]. In other words, the evidence for krill oil over fish oil is not settled.
I am sharing what I read and what I found interesting. I am not telling you what to take, how much, or which product. Please ask your doctor or pharmacist before taking any supplement, especially if you take blood thinners or have a bleeding disorder.
In part 3 I will pull this together with other things that protect the brain, including the “golden triangle” of exercise, DHA and sleep.
Blessings, Koot
Sources
- SOURCE NEEDED: Dr Mercola's article on krill oil, which Koot says calls krill oil the best source of omega-3 fatty acids and explains how essential they are for brain cells. Koot to supply the title and URL of the article. Treated in the text as Dr Mercola's view, not established fact. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: the AI chat (ChatGPT) conversation about the article. Koot to confirm the tool's name and that he is happy to say "an AI chat tool". Everything attributed to "the chat" is unverified. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: in krill oil the omega-3 fats EPA and DHA are bound to phospholipids (the chat's summary of Dr Mercola's argument; article needed). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: phospholipids are the building blocks of every cell membrane, especially in the brain, nerves, eyes and heart (the chat's summary of Dr Mercola; no source named). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: because krill-oil omega-3 is bound to phospholipids it is built into membranes more easily and is often better available than ordinary fish oil; fish oil carries DHA in triglycerides, krill oil in phospholipids (Dr Mercola's argument as summarised by the chat; article needed). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: phospholipids help keep membranes supple, act as gatekeepers for what moves in and out of cells, and may help DHA reach the brain through the blood-brain barrier (Dr Mercola as summarised by the chat; article needed). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: krill oil contains phosphatidylcholine, which supplies choline, the raw material for acetylcholine, a neurotransmitter for memory, learning, attention and concentration (Dr Mercola and the chat; article needed). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: krill oil naturally contains astaxanthin, an antioxidant that protects omega-3 fats from oxidation and gives krill oil its red colour (chat; Dr Mercola's article needed). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: the brain has about 86 billion neurons, each with thousands of connections, and their membranes are made largely of phospholipids and fatty acids (AI chat; no source named). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: DHA is built into cell membranes, especially in the brain, retina and nerve cells, with high concentrations in the brain; the "steel in reinforced concrete" image (AI chat; no source named). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: when DHA is plentiful membranes stay supple, receptors work better, signals move more easily and new connections form more easily; research links DHA with normal brain development and function (AI chat; no source named). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: John Ratey's book *Spark* shows that exercise raises BDNF, stimulates new connections, promotes neuroplasticity and helps new neurons survive (the chat's description of the book; Koot named the book. Exact claims and page references needed). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: the idea that if BDNF is the "building foreman", DHA is one of the "bricks", so exercise and enough omega-3 may complement each other for brain health (AI chat's own reasoning; no source named). ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: some studies show higher availability of phospholipid-bound DHA, but it is not yet definitively proven that this leads to better long-term outcomes than high-quality fish oil (AI chat's own caveat; the studies are not named). ↑



