I want to use ice cream to show the difference between plain, real ice cream, the way our grandmothers made it, and what we buy at the shop today. Just look at how many substances come with it. Many of them are already processed, like the sweeteners. Almost everything has changed.
One caution before the lists. The lists below are typical, not exact. Recipes and labels differ from product to product [1][2].
Ice cream the old way
A natural ice cream can be made from these [1]:
- whole milk
- fresh cream
- egg yolk
- sugar
- salt
- real vanilla or vanilla extract
For other flavours you can add fresh fruit, cocoa or chocolate, or nuts.
In my view that is a reasonably balanced treat. A bit short on vegetables and heavy on sugar, yes, but with fat and protein, thanks to the eggs.
Ice cream from the factory
A typical factory ice cream can contain [2]:
- water
- milk or milk powder, milk solids, whey or whey powder, milk proteins
- cream or milk fat
- vegetable oil or vegetable fat
- sugar, glucose syrup, glucose-fructose syrup, dextrose, maltodextrin
- modified starch
- salt
Emulsifiers: mono- and diglycerides (E471), lecithin (E322), polysorbate 80 (E433) [2].
Stabilisers and thickeners: guar gum (E412), locust bean gum (E410), xanthan gum (E415), carrageenan (E407), cellulose gum or CMC (E466) [2].
Depending on the product there can also be flavourings, colourings, acidity regulators, preservatives, and chocolate, fruit or caramel flavourings and sauces [2].
The big difference: natural ice cream can be made from a handful of simple ingredients, while a factory ice cream can easily have 15 to 25 or more [2]. Again, the exact list differs a lot from one product to the next.
Something else: water can be added, and air is worked into the ice cream during the process. A litre of ice cream is certainly not a kilogram. It is more like 0.5 to 0.7 kg [3].
My argument
My argument is that processed food contains a great many additives that we do not need, even if they are not necessarily harmful. In my understanding, they put an extra load on the body, which has to clear them out again [4].
We do not eat ice cream every day, but many of us eat snacks all the time. I could eat a packet of cheese curls in one go. So this is what the list of typical cheese curl ingredients looks like [5].
What is in a cheese curl?
Typical factory cheese curls are made mainly from [5]:
- maize meal or maize grits, the base of the curl;
- vegetable oil, usually sunflower, canola or palm oil, depending on the brand;
- cheese powder or cheese flavouring. Sometimes it contains real cheese, but often it is a compounded flavour powder;
- salt;
- milk powder or whey powder;
- sugar or dextrose, in some products;
- maltodextrin, a processed carbohydrate that helps carry the flavours;
- MSG (monosodium glutamate), a flavour enhancer, in some products, and other flavour enhancers;
- artificial or natural flavourings;
- colourings, to give the strong yellow or orange “cheese” colour;
- acidity regulators, to control taste and shelf life;
- emulsifiers, which help fat and other ingredients mix;
- preservatives or antioxidants, in some products, to help the oil and the product keep longer.
The curl itself is really mostly maize. The maize mixture is pushed through a mould under high pressure and heat. When it comes out it puffs up into that light, crisp curl. Then the oil and the cheese or flavour powder are applied [6].
So what do I make of it?
Do you see what I mean? You do not need it. It is tasty, and I do not think it does us any good. Being overweight and unfit is unhealthy, and in my view the extra weight comes mainly from unnatural food and unnecessary snacks [7]. Sugar is lovely. But not everything that is lovely is healthy.
I rest my case!
To be continued.
Blessings, Koot.
Sources
- SOURCE NEEDED: the typical ingredients of natural, home-style ice cream (whole milk, fresh cream, egg yolk, sugar, salt, real vanilla; fruit, cocoa or nuts for flavour). Koot says lists differ per product. Needs a real recipe or a food-composition source. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: the typical ingredients of factory ice cream, including the emulsifiers and stabilisers with their E-numbers as Koot gave them (E471, E322, E433, E412, E410, E415, E407, E466), and the claim of "15 to 25 or more" ingredients. Needs real product labels (not named in the post) and a source for the E-numbers. Koot says the exact list differs a lot per product. The list reads like text from an AI chat. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: that air is worked into ice cream, so that 1 litre weighs about 0.5 to 0.7 kg. No source named by Koot. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: Koot's statement that processed food contains additives we do not need, that they are not necessarily harmful, and that they put a load on the body to clear them. No source named by Koot. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: the typical ingredients of factory cheese curls (list above). The list reads like text from an AI chat and differs per product. Needs real labels or a food-composition source. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: how cheese curls are made (maize mixture pushed through a mould under high pressure and heat, puffs up, then oil and cheese or flavour powder are applied). No source named by Koot. ↑
- SOURCE NEEDED: Koot's statement that being overweight comes mainly from unnatural food and unnecessary snacks. No source named by Koot. ↑



