Healthy, wealthy and wise

Notes on health, money and faith, by Koot Jordaan

Health › Metabolism

Metabolism: cholesterol, the misunderstood molecule

In the series MetabolismPart 8 of 8

I came across Jay Feldman while looking into what keeps us healthy. He is part of a group that focuses on our metabolism [1].

The word “metabolism” comes from Greek: meta means change and ballein means to throw or to change. Literally, “to change” [2]. In biology it covers all the chemical processes that turn food, oxygen and nutrients into energy and new body material [2]. I think of it as the body’s factory: raw materials in, energy and building material out. If it goes off the rails, illness follows.

Cholesterol is usually cast as the villain, the main reason for heart attacks and strokes [3]. Feldman explains it differently. Read what follows as one person’s notes on a video, put together with the help of an AI assistant. It is not medical advice.

Nobody should change or stop any medication without talking to their own doctor first.

Why your body needs cholesterol

Cholesterol got a bad name because it is linked to heart disease, yet it is one of the most important molecules in the body. We cannot live without it, and every cell needs it [3]. Its main jobs:

  1. Cell membranes. It gives every cell wall strength and flexibility, and helps control what moves in and out [4].
  2. The brain. About 20 to 25% of the body’s cholesterol is in the brain, which is only about 2% of body weight. The brain makes almost all its own, for synapses, repair, development, memory and learning [5].
  3. Myelin. The insulation around nerves is largely fat, with cholesterol an important part. It lets nerve signals travel hundreds of times faster, like the plastic round an electric wire [6].
  4. Steroid hormones. Cortisol, aldosterone, testosterone, oestrogen, progesterone and DHEA are made from it [7].
  5. Vitamin D. Vitamin D production in the skin starts with a cholesterol-derived substance [8].
  6. Bile. The liver makes bile acids from it, needed to break down fat and absorb vitamins A, D, E and K [9].
  7. Repair. The body uses it to build new membranes when tissue is damaged. That is one reason it can collect at damaged blood vessels, although the cause of the damage matters [10].
  8. Babies. It is needed for the foetus’s brain and nervous system, and breast milk naturally contains a lot of it [11].
  9. The immune system. It plays a part in immune cells, cell-to-cell communication, and some repair and inflammation processes [12].

An adult has roughly 30 to 40 trillion cells, nearly all with cholesterol in their membranes (red blood cells are the exception), and the liver makes about 1 to 2 grams a day even if you eat very little [13]. It does not mean higher is always better. The health effect depends on the whole picture: LDL and HDL, metabolic health, inflammation, blood pressure, smoking, diabetes, genetics and more [14].

Feldman’s view: why cholesterol may rise

This is Feldman’s view as I understood it, not settled science. His starting question was why cholesterol is high and how to normalise it without medication [15]. His main message is that high cholesterol is usually not the real problem but a sign that something else is going wrong, so the aim should be to find the cause, not just push the number down [15].

He names three main reasons why it can rise:

1. An inflamed or unhealthy gut. He says the most common cause is bacterial toxins (endotoxins, or LPS) leaking from the gut into the blood. Cholesterol helps bind them, so the body raises it as protection [16]. Signs he mentions include bloating, gas, bowel trouble, brain fog, skin problems and joint pain. His focus is gut health, good stomach acid, enough bile flow and easily digested food [16].

2. A sluggish thyroid. He says the thyroid largely decides how fast cholesterol is used. If it runs slowly, less is used and it builds up in the blood, a link he says has been known for over 100 years [17]. He feels many people only get a TSH test, and that T3, T4 and reverse T3 should be looked at too [17]. Signs he mentions include tiredness, cold hands and feet, dry skin, hair loss and weight gain [17].

3. Too much fat and too few carbohydrates. Here he differs from many keto followers. He says that on lots of fat and few carbohydrates, cholesterol and LDL often rise. That need not mean you are sick, only that your body mainly uses fat as fuel. Over time he sees downsides, such as lower T3, a slower metabolism, more stress hormones, poor sleep and less energy, and he suggests enough easily digested carbohydrates rather than staying very low for long [18].

These signs have many possible causes, so talk to your doctor.

Where to be careful

I also asked the AI assistant where Feldman’s views are well supported and where they are contested. None of this is checked.

Said to be well supported: look at the whole person, not one blood test; an underactive thyroid is a known cause of raised cholesterol; inflammation and poor metabolic health matter for heart and blood-vessel risk; and lifestyle (sleep, movement, weight, stress, food) stays the most important treatment [19].

Said to be more contested [20]:

  • Gut toxins. LPS can promote inflammation, but it has not been established as the main reason for high cholesterol in most people.
  • Low-carbohydrate diets. Some studies show LDL rising strongly in some people on keto or very low-carbohydrate diets, while others see metabolic improvements. It differs between individuals.
  • Statins. Feldman is very critical of them. They do not fix underlying lifestyle problems, but there is strong clinical evidence that they can lower the risk of further heart and blood-vessel events in some high-risk groups, for example people who have already had a heart attack or who have familial hypercholesterolaemia. So it is not right to write statins off as useless for everybody.

If you take a statin or any other medicine, do not change or stop it without your doctor.

What I take from it

Feldman’s most useful message, I think, is not a new “miracle diet” but a different way of looking at cholesterol. High cholesterol is often a warning light on the dashboard, not necessarily the engine that is broken.

If your cholesterol is high, questions for your doctor are: Is my thyroid working normally? Is there chronic inflammation? Is my gut healthy? Is there insulin resistance? How are my sleep and stress? What do my diet and body composition look like?

That is more rounded than looking only at the number.

Sources

  1. SOURCE NEEDED: the video by Jay Feldman on cholesterol. Koot gave no link and no title: video URL and title needed. Also needed: who Jay Feldman is and the "group that focuses on our metabolism" he belongs to. ↑
  2. SOURCE NEEDED: the Greek origin of the word "metabolism" (*meta*, *ballein*) and the definition of metabolism in biology. No source named by Koot. ↑
  3. SOURCE NEEDED: that cholesterol is blamed for heart attacks and strokes, and that it is one of the most important molecules in the body, that we cannot live without it and every cell needs it. From an AI-written list that Koot pasted; unverified. ↑
  4. SOURCE NEEDED: cholesterol in cell membranes (strength, flexibility, control of what moves in and out). From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  5. SOURCE NEEDED: the brain holds about 20 to 25% of the body's cholesterol while being about 2% of body weight; the brain makes nearly all its own; its uses (synapses, repair of neurons, development, memory and learning). FIGURE. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  6. SOURCE NEEDED: myelin is largely fat with cholesterol as an important part, and nerve signals travel "hundreds of times faster". FIGURE. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  7. SOURCE NEEDED: cortisol, aldosterone, testosterone, oestrogen, progesterone and DHEA are made from cholesterol. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  8. SOURCE NEEDED: vitamin D synthesis begins with a cholesterol-derived substance in the skin. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  9. SOURCE NEEDED: the liver uses cholesterol to make bile acids, needed for fat digestion and absorption of vitamins A, D, E and K. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  10. SOURCE NEEDED: cholesterol is used to build new membranes when tissue is damaged, and its build-up at damaged vessels is part of that repair. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  11. SOURCE NEEDED: cholesterol is needed for foetal growth, brain and nervous-system development, and breast milk contains much of it. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  12. SOURCE NEEDED: cholesterol's role in immune-cell function, cell communication and repair and inflammation processes. From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  13. SOURCE NEEDED: an adult has about 30 to 40 trillion cells; all but red blood cells have cholesterol in their membranes; the liver makes about 1 to 2 grams of cholesterol per day. FIGURE. From the AI-written list; unverified. (Koot's earlier email gave about 30 trillion.) ↑
  14. SOURCE NEEDED: that the health effect of cholesterol depends on the whole picture (LDL and HDL, metabolic health, inflammation, blood pressure, smoking, diabetes, genetics). From the AI-written list; unverified. ↑
  15. SOURCE NEEDED: Jay Feldman's main message that high cholesterol is usually a sign of something else going wrong, and his starting question (why cholesterol is high and how to normalise it without medication). Koot's understanding of the video, via an AI summary of the transcript; unverified. MEDICATION. ↑
  16. SOURCE NEEDED: Feldman's claim that gut endotoxins (LPS) are the most common cause of raised cholesterol, the signs he lists, and what he suggests. Understood from the video via AI summary; unverified. ↑
  17. SOURCE NEEDED: Feldman's claims about the thyroid and cholesterol (link known for 100+ years; TSH, T3, T4 and reverse T3 tests; the signs he lists). Understood from the video via AI summary; unverified. ↑
  18. SOURCE NEEDED: Feldman's claims about high-fat, low-carbohydrate eating, LDL, the downsides he lists and his carbohydrate recommendation. Understood from the video via AI summary; unverified. ↑
  19. SOURCE NEEDED: the AI assistant's statements of where Feldman's views are well supported (whole-person approach; hypothyroidism as a known cause of raised cholesterol; inflammation and metabolic health in cardiovascular risk; lifestyle as main treatment). AI-CHAT; unverified. ↑
  20. SOURCE NEEDED: the AI assistant's statements of where Feldman's views are contested (LPS and cholesterol; LDL on keto or very low-carbohydrate diets; statins and the evidence in high-risk groups such as after a heart attack or with familial hypercholesterolaemia). AI-CHAT; unverified. MEDICATION. ↑
All 8 parts in this series
  1. Metabolism: what is metabolic syndrome?
  2. Metabolism: ten warning signs your metabolism is slipping
  3. Metabolism: how your cells make energy
  4. Metabolism: how it goes wrong, and the way back
  5. Metabolism: how to lose weight without dieting
  6. Metabolism: what should we eat?
  7. Metabolism: what is really in processed food?
  8. Metabolism: cholesterol, the misunderstood molecule

More from Health

All Health articles →